Bankruptcy: U.S. firms may
rush to bankruptcy before changes
Thu Sep 1, 2005 1:00 PM ET By Jonathan Stempel
NEW YORK, Sept 1 (Reuters) - Ailing companies
may rush to the courthouse in the next six weeks ahead of
sweeping revisions to U.S. bankruptcy laws -- and experts
say it's probably a good idea.
Beginning Oct. 17, it will become tougher and
more expensive for companies to seek protection under Chapter
11 of the bankruptcy code. Creditors will gain power, and
businesses, large and small, will have to reorganize faster.
"We're going to see some large filings
between now and October 17," says Lynn LoPucki, a bankruptcy
law professor at the University of California at Los Angeles.
Speculation has risen that the ailing Delta
Air Lines Inc. <DAL.N> and Northwest Airlines Corp.
<NWAC.O> will, or should, seek court protection soon.
Standard & Poor's said higher oil prices
after Hurricane Katrina ripped across the U.S. Gulf Coast
may hasten a Delta bankruptcy, which it said on Wednesday
it expects "within weeks." Delta declined to comment
on market speculation.
Evan Flaschen, co-head of Bingham McCutchen
LLP's bankruptcy practice in Hartford, Connecticut, who represents
large institutional and distressed debt investors, says the
new law could prompt a "sea change."
"Recent trends have been too much in favor
of debtor control to the detriment of creditors," he
says. "This legislation helps level the playing field."
There were 34,817 business bankruptcies in the
year ended Sept. 30, 2004, down 4 percent from the prior year,
according to the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts.
Experts predict filings will drop after the
law changes, and businesses may exit bankruptcy weaker than
if they file now.
"Businesses ought to file before October
17 unless they are dead certain they have business plans to
stay out of bankruptcy for a minimum of two years," says
Bill Rochelle, a partner at Fulbright & Jaworski LLP in
New York. "A CEO will look pretty stupid if he puts a
company in Chapter 11 in December."
THREE CHANGES
Experts cite three big changes that will affect
businesses.
First, companies will have for only 18 months
the exclusive right to present their own reorganization plans.
Exclusivity blocks disgruntled creditors from offering alternative
schemes.
Judges now can extend exclusivity almost indefinitely.
That helps United Airlines Inc., for example, which after
33 months in bankruptcy still has an exclusive right to file
a reorganization plan.
Another change bars payments of retention bonuses
except when executives prove they are entertaining other job
offers. This was intended to stop companies from rewarding
executives -- including those who drove companies into bankruptcy
-- as they cut jobs, wages and benefits elsewhere.
Enron Corp. awarded some $80 million to employees
it considered too important to lose just before it filed for
Chapter 11 -- and fired thousands.
Some judges are already cracking down on retention
pay. In June, a judge excised top officers from a bid by US
Airways Group Inc. <UAIRQ.OB> to pay severance and retention
awards to some 1,800 executives and managers.
Rochelle says the bonus prohibition "will
make it very difficult" for companies to keep their best
mid-level managers.
CATCHING ONE'S BREATH
A third, widely criticized change gives companies
just 210 days to decide whether to keep or reject leases for
items such as stores or, in the case of airlines, even airport
gates.
This may bedevil retailers hoping to close underperforming
outlets. Many seek Chapter 11 protection in January or February,
before they pay for holiday merchandise.
But 210 days won't get them to the next Christmas,
and may force premature decisions on which locations to keep
open or close.
"The draconian lease provision is a mistake,"
says Robert Zinman, a St. John's University law professor
and former president of the American Bankruptcy Institute.
"Although I have some sympathy for landlords, this goes
too far."
For the courts themselves, LoPucki expects intensified
competition for the biggest cases, now often brought in New
York and Delaware. He expects judges to find ways around the
limits on exclusivity and bonuses, but says limits on leases
appear ironclad.
Some groups like the new law.
"These reforms will not eliminate delays,
but will certainly reduce them," says Wayne Abernathy,
an executive policy director at the American Bankers Association.
"If you file Chapter 11, it gives you time to catch your
breath -- and then get on with being a business."
Airlines aren't divulging their plans. Delta
has said Chapter 11 is possible if its finances worsen too
much. And Northwest Chief Executive Doug Steenland has called
the Oct. 17 date "one of the factors" in his decision-making
process.
Henry Sommer, co-editor of the "Collier
on Bankruptcy" reference work, says filing soon eliminates
uncertainty over how the new law will be applied. "When
billions of dollars of assets are at stake," he says,
"you don't want to take chances."
|